And here's exactly what that means for your company

McKinsey's latest research has confirmed what many of us have been experiencing in the trenches: AI investments aren't delivering the promised returns. But the reason isn't what most people think.

​It's not that AI doesn't work. It's that companies are trying to bolt AI onto business models that weren't designed for it.

According to McKinsey's analysis, companies are pouring unprecedented amounts into AI initiatives, yet the majority report disappointing results. Sound familiar?

​Here's the pattern we see repeatedly:

The mistake: Treating AI like a software upgrade instead of a business transformation catalyst.

Most AI implementations fail because they're based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what AI actually does.
AI doesn't just make your existing processes faster. It changes what's possible entirely.

When you try to squeeze AI into your current business model, you're like someone trying to use a smartphone as a better landline. You're missing the point entirely.

The real opportunity: AI allows you to reimagine your entire approach to customers, offers, and efficiency.

Based on our work with dozens of companies implementing AI successfully, the transformation comes down to rethinking three core elements:

Traditional thinking: "How can AI help us serve our existing customers better?"

AI-first thinking: "What new customer experiences become possible with AI? Who can we now serve that we couldn't before?"

Example: Instead of using AI to speed up traditional customer support, companies like Intercom are using AI to provide instant, personalized product recommendations that feel like having a dedicated consultant available 24/7.
​
The question isn't how to automate your current customer journey. It's how to design entirely new customer journeys that leverage AI's unique capabilities.

Traditional thinking: "How can AI make our current products better?"

AI-first thinking: "What entirely new offers become possible when AI is core to our value proposition?"

Example: Netflix didn't just use AI to improve their DVD recommendation system. They used AI insights to create entirely new offers — original content based on viewing data that traditional studios could never access.
​
The most successful AI implementations create new categories of value, not just better versions of existing value.

Traditional thinking: "How can AI automate our current processes?"

AI-first thinking: "What if we designed our processes from scratch knowing AI would be central to how they work?"

Example: Instead of using AI to speed up manual invoice processing, companies like Stripe reimagined the entire payment process around AI-powered fraud detection, risk assessment, and automated compliance.
​
The goal isn't to make broken processes faster. It's to design processes that get smarter over time.

With the R3 Framework, we've developed what we call "Metamapping" — a systematic approach to redesigning your business model for AI success before you write a single line of code.

Here's how it works:
​
​Phase 1: Current State Analysis

Map your existing customer journey, value propositions, and operational processes
Identify where AI is being "bolted on" vs. where it could be foundational
Assess which assumptions about your business model need to be challenged

Phase 2: AI-First Redesign

Reimagine your customer experience assuming AI capabilities from day one
Design new offers that leverage AI as a core differentiator
Architect processes that learn and improve automatically

Phase 3: Implementation Roadmap

Create a step-by-step plan for transitioning from current state to AI-optimized state
Identify quick wins that demonstrate the new model's potential
​Build feedback loops that ensure continuous improvement

When you rethink your business model for AI instead of trying to retrofit AI onto your existing model, something remarkable happens: you create compound advantages.

Traditional AI implementation: Linear improvements in efficiency

AI-first business design: Exponential improvements in capability

The companies that understand this distinction aren't just getting better results from AI. They're creating entirely new competitive moats.

McKinsey's research isn't just an observation — it's a roadmap. The companies that will thrive in the AI era aren't those with the best AI tools. They're the ones who rethink their entire business model around AI's unique capabilities.

Ask yourself:

If you were starting your company today, knowing what AI can do, how would you design your customer experience differently?
What offers could you create that your competitors can't match because they're stuck in pre-AI thinking?
Which of your processes could be reimagined to get smarter over time instead of just faster?

The window for AI-first business design is closing. As more companies figure this out, the competitive advantage will shift from "having AI" to "being designed for AI."

The question isn't whether you'll eventually need to rethink your business model. It's whether you'll do it proactively while you still have time to lead your market, or reactively while you're trying to catch up.

Ready to rethink your customers, offers, and efficiency for the AI era?

With the R3 Framework, we help companies design AI-first business models that create compound advantages. Our Metamapping process ensures you're building on solid strategic foundations, not just implementing the latest technology.

Join the waitlist to learn how we can help you turn McKinsey's warning into your competitive advantage.